Closet Sci-Fi Geek

Closet Sci-Fi Geek

science fiction news and reviews for closet nerds

Closet Sci-Fi Geek RSS Feed
 
 
 
 

Movies: Does Narnia Live Up to the Hype?

By - Saturday, December 10th, 2005

Gosh…I’m not quite sure how to say this. I’m a huge fan of The Chronicles of Narnia books. These were my favorite books as a child. I read them over and over again. I still have my worn and weathered Narnia boxed set in my bookshelf…it’s probably 25 years old now.

But I left my viewing of “The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe” with mixed feelings. The movie was great, and I really liked it a lot, and yet, I am left feeling somewhat hollow and empty, as if something was missing.

And I guess that would be the essence of my review – the film was really really good, but not mindblowing.

Maybe my expectations are simply too high now. “The Lord of the Rings” films really raised the bar, in my mind. Those films were beyond expectations – almost as perfect as they could have been. There’s a reason why “Return of the King” won an Academy Award. It set the standard for fantasy that actually took itself seriously.

This first installment of the “Narnia” films on the other hand, lacks that extra “oomph” and quality that would really set it apart as a great film. It’s a classic, but more like “Harry Potter” in tone and execution – more childlike, I suppose.

Which is really alright. After all, “Narnia” is for children, ultimately. And it’s the children in the film that really make this movie stand out. Lucy, in particular, is played to exquisite perfection by 9-year-old Georgie Henley. She is absolutely astonishing and carries the film.

All the other children are also fantastic (even sniveling Edmund, who is truly annoying in the book version). Overall, it’s the casting that saves this film. Some have complained about the choice of Tilda Swinton as the White Witch, I found her absolutely “chilling” (pardon the snow reference). She just kicks ass. In the final battle scene, she wields two swords and would give Darth Maul a run for his money.

The film is a little slow to start. (I might have enjoyed this pace more, however, if it weren’t for the multiple groups of antsy teenages milling around my seating area changing their minds over where to sit for the first half-hour.) Once the story starts rolling, it picks up speed and just gets better and better as it continues.

The climax (in case you hadn’t heard) is this absolutely stunning battle scene, and this is one part of the film that does rival the Tolkien films in quality.

“The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe” is a tough story to tell in one film and still keep the sense of scope and epic quality. The plotline stays close to the book (without being excruciating about it as with the first “Harry Potter” film). The appearance of Aslan still felt a little abrupt to me, and I was left wondering about timelines and how Peter was able to amass an army in what seemed like a few hours. (I’ll admit, it’s been a while since I read the books.) Minor complaints aside, I can’t imagine how they could have done better with the plot without ruining the integrity of the story.

As to the question of special effects – once again, my reviews are mixed. Some of the talking animals were amazingly life-like. Talking beavers are hard to do well, and these worked. It seems to me, however, that the effects team who handled the creatures and animals with such aplomb must have been different from the team handling background scenery and larger scale effects – this is where “Narnia” suffers. (Backdrops were a bit obvious in some points, and the river scene was just not well done at all.)

In spite of a few complaints, by the end of the movie I was won over. It used to be that fantasy films were box office jokes. (Anyone remember “Willow”?) I am so glad to be living in a time where technology allows us to bring these classic stories to life.

Now I’m just hoping this does well enough that we can see “Prince Caspian” (the next installment) get made. It is the later books in the series that were actually my favorites, and more fantasy onscreen can’t hurt, so let’s keep the franchise going.

4 Responses to “Movies: Does Narnia Live Up to the Hype?”

  1. 1
    Damoon:

    Im sorry Im french
    Narnia sucks ?

    damoondamoon.blogspot.com

  2. 2
    Ron:

    I felt the same way about the Lord of the Rings movies. They were great movies, but they weren’t the books and I felt something was missing.

    But I went to the movies with the understanding that they weren’t the books on film, but rather a different story based on the books and that I should judge the movies as they stand – not on how well they mirrored the books.

    I’ve never been a Narnia fan. By the time I discovered the books, I had already gotten into Tolkien and the Narnia books seemed “childish” to me. I’ve only recently started to read them and, while nice, they don’t have the same impact on me that they probably would have if I had read them when I was a kid.

    I’ll probably pick up a copy on DVD when it comes out, watch it and then give it to my nephews.

  3. 3
    pjk:

    For some reason, the Narnia thing completely passed me by. I know nothing about the story or characters, and feel like I did about Harry Potter about 6 months prior to the first movie opening. Then I picked up HP Book One and was hooked.

    LOTR was definitely a labor of love for the filmmakers and showed what you can do when you try to stay true to the spirit of the original work. (Warner Bros is still recovering from f*ing up Batman, but Batman Begins is a good start…) Stuff was missing from LOTR, but sheesh – at three hours plus apiece, I’ll cut Jackson some slack.

    So with Narnia…should I read the book first, or just see the movie?

    On an unrelated note, and the Batman thing reminded me of it, you should dig up an obscure film starring Christian Bale called “Equilibrium”. This was the movie that convinced the execs that Bale would make a kickass Batman. I won’t go into the plot more than to say that I know where the Wachowski’s got the inspiration for Neo’s outfits in the latter two films in the Matrix trilogy.

    Take care,

    pjk

Leave a Reply

IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)

What is 6 + 4 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:

 

December 2005
M T W T F S S
« Nov   Jan »
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Tags

Categories

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Bad Behavior has blocked 253 access attempts in the last 7 days.

Buy cialis Pittsburgh
buy viagra online at
online viagra uk
Buy viagra Washington
barebones
cheapest singulair
buy viagra soft online
buy viagra vermont
viagra 100 free shipping
cheap altace online cheap
Buy viagra New Orleans
buy cheap evista online
buy norvasc usa
buy generic norvasc online
Buy viagra Richmond
Buy viagra Portland
Buy viagra Oxnard
cheap cialis generic mastercard
Buy levitra Arlington
buy viagra viagra online
cheapest prilosec
buy viagra phuket
Buy levitra Denver
cheap viagra for men
buy viagra london
generic viagra does it work
online viagra canada
cheapest zocor
buy canada diovan hydrochloride
cheap geneirc viagra 100
Buy levitra Houston
buy cheap buspar
Buy cialis Arlington
purchasing viagra in venezuela
discount buspar
Buy levitra Columbus
buy claritin
buy generic cialis without prescription
buy premarin
Buy levitra Albuquerque
Buy levitra Phoenix
Buy cialis Tulsa
buy viagra or levitra
Buy cialis Rome
generic viagra fast delivery
buy viagra san jose
cheap gen viagra bi
online viagra overnight
buy viagra online australia
Buy viagra Buffalo
buy hublot watches
buy generic allegra d
generic viagra deals
buy viagra onli ne
buy designer watches
bye viagra
buy levitra viagra
Buy cialis Oxnard
buy cialis re
Buy cialis Memphis
buy generic online prilosec
cheap altace
buy norvasc online
buy viagra online cheapest
Buy cialis El Paso
generic viagra uk
buy viagra canada review
Buy levitra Milwaukee
buy viagra usa
online viagra pharmacie miami florida
buy norvasc 10mg
buy now allegra
generic viagra trial pack
Buy levitra Fort Worth
buy tamiflu
buy norvasc cheap
buy cheap generic cialis
buy imitrex
cheap cialis
cheap generic nolvadex order
buy cheap levitra online
Buy cialis Modesto
buy cialis softtabs
buy discount buspar
buy viagra by pill
onlinenmru ultram
buy canada online zyban
Buy levitra Riverside
buy viagra california
Buy viagra Tacoma
buy viagra orlando
Buy viagra Omaha
buy levitra line
buy generic tramadol no prescription
cheap actos
generic viagra without visa
buy viagra tampa
buy cialis viagra
generic viagra canada
buy viagra safeway pharmacy
buy generic cialis softtabs
cheap generic cialis pills
cheap allegra online pharmacy
Buy cialis Denver
Buy levitra New Orleans
Buy levitra Buffalo
generic viagra capsules
viagra 100
buy discount watches
buy nolvadex online
generic viagra caverta veega generic viagra
buy lasix fast
Buy levitra Baltimore
Buy cialis San Antonio
cheap cipro
buy zantac
online viagra levitra cialis
buy viagra ups
generic viagra today atlanta
Buy levitra Richmond
online viagra store
generic viagra purchase
online viagra student loan consolidation
cheap buspar
buy viagra illinois
buy herbal viagra
Buy cialis Phoenix
buy viagra online india
german viagra substitutes
buy singulair
buy zithromax
buy corum
buy viagra online canada
Buy viagra Phoenix
buy generic singulair
buy mens watches
Buy levitra Mesa
buy cheap online viagra
buy ultram
online uk viagra
buy cheap generic propecia
propecia acne
buy viagra prescription
buy panerai watches
Buy viagra Memphis
Buy levitra San Antonio
buy lasix
Buy viagra Austin
buy viagra online online
buy viagra new york
buy viagra generic
buy cialis pill
generic in usa viagra
Buy cialis Washington
cheap cialis from shanghai
Buy levitra Tucson
buy cialis today
buy nolvadex
buy replica wrist watches online
buy cheap generic nexium
Buy levitra Tulsa
online ordering viagra
buy zocor
buy replica watches
Buy cialis Columbus
generic viagra work
buy generic viagra
buy prilosec
cheap generic norvasc online
cheapest ultram
cheapest protonix
Buy levitra Tacoma
Buy cialis Baltimore
buy diflucan
generic viagra caverta veega
generic viagra us pharmacy
online store viagra
buy viagra pills
cheapest zyban
cheapest premarin
Buy viagra Albuquerque
buy cheap online ultram
Buy cialis Louisville
Buy levitra Omaha
viagra 10 generic
buy viagra in amsterdam
buy generic viagra pharmacy online
buy norvasc
online viagra cialis ricetta
buy generic cialis uk
online viagra pharmacy
buy viagra for less
generic viagra quality
buy from pharmacy us viagra
buy viagra now
cheap est xenical online
purchasing viagra online
generic viagra rd
buspar online
generic viagra usa
buy buy prilosec online
online prescription viagra without
cheap viagra from mexico
cheap cialis sale online
buy viagra in chicago
Buy viagra Pittsburgh
Buy viagra Rome
buy generic xenical
ophthalmic cipro
Buy cialis Fresno
cheap altace no prescription
phisher viagra
buy viagra s journal
Buy cialis Portland
buy norvasc drug
buy viagra in malaysia
buy clomid
buy nexium where
Buy cialis Tacoma
generic viagra fast shipping
generic viagra cialis
Buy levitra Long Beach
buy cailis viagra singapore
buy depakote
cheap canada generic levitra
Buy cialis Richmond
buy cialis where
Buy cialis Milwaukee
online prescription soma viagra zoloft
buy coumadin
cheap celebrex
buy neurontin
buy cheap nolvadex online
buy viagra meds online
buy cheap generic norvasc
online zyrtec
cheapest propecia
buy evista
buy lopressor
Buy cialis Detroit
generic viagra pills
buy viagra online canadian
buy viagra cheap online
viagra $5
Buy levitra Washington
buy now cialis
purchase zocor
buy neurontin online
cheap generic substitute viagra
buy cialis we
buy linecom soma
cheap generic viagra 1.00
buy synthroid
buy cheap online soma
buy viagra sale
Buy levitra Austin
Buy levitra Detroit
cheap generic drugs caverta
buy cheap generic viagra
Buy levitra Charlotte
cheapest viagra
Buy cialis Indianapolis
cheapest pravachol
online viagra consultation
online viagra australia
cheap drugs viagra cialas
dd3 memory
purchase tamiflu
buy viagra cheap prices
online viagra with insurance
buy viagra ebay
buy viagra discrete uk
Buy cialis Austin
buy generic viagra usa
Buy cialis Atlanta
buy generic online zyrtec
Buy levitra Indianapolis
buy avandia
cheap free shipping soma
generic viagra discount
Buy viagra Houston
cheap viagra
buy viagra sacramento
Buy cialis Kansas City
buy buspar online
buy viagra florida
online sale viagra
buy viagra with paypal
cheapest xenical
buy viagra discrete england
Buy viagra Denver
buy generic soma
buy viagra onlines
cheap viagra fast shipping
Buy viagra Atlanta
generic viagra uk supplies
buy cheap effexor xr
buy generic href info levitra
buy levitra onlines
cheap drugs canada protonix
buy viagra in boston
generic viagra caverta cialis cheap
buy cialis tadalafil
buy viagra in spain
buy viagra in bangkok
Buy viagra Indianapolis
buy diovan
Buy cialis Fort Worth
buy viagra online buy
buy generic propecia online
buy lasix online
cheap generic india viagra
Buy cialis New Orleans
cialis
buy kamagra viagra
buy atarax
buy viagra texas
propecia alternative
online uk viagra sales
buy viagra securely online
buy generic viagra img
buy tenormin
buy keyword viagra
Buy viagra Kansas City
buy lexapro
Buy levitra Newark
buy norvasc 5mg
buy viagra jacksonville
generic indian viagra
buy nolvadex mexico
buy n viagra
cheap generic viagra deals
buy viagra fedex
buy viagra now online
Buy viagra Long Beach
Buy cialis Omaha
online viagra sales
buy viagra using paypal
purchasing viagra online for cheap
buy nexium
buy retin-a
buy viagra in england
generic viagra drugstore india
phizer viagra
buy levitra
cheap genric viagra online
buy prevacid
amd barebones
buy viagra in vancouver
buy viagra dallas
buy somas
buy levitra us
Buy cialis Riverside
online prescription for viagra
Buy levitra San Francisco
philippines viagra
buy viagra order viagra
Buy viagra Milwaukee
cheap cialis for you
cheapest soma
Buy levitra Atlanta
buy cialis soft
Buy cialis San Francisco
generic form of viagra
buy viagra soft
Buy levitra Pittsburgh
buy viagra online order
buy viagra pill
Buy viagra San Francisco
buy montblanc
buy cheap generic pravachol
buy soma
generic viagra drugs order brand pill
buy generic cialis online
buy viagra in london
buy viagra professional
buy viagra online paypal
Buy cialis Oakland
buy cheap online xenical
buy lasix nextday
generic viagra cialis pills
generic viagra uk online pharmacy
buy paxil
cheap generic propecia finasteride
Buy viagra El Paso
buy viagra internet
buy viagra inte
buy viagra for cheap
buy cheap kamagra uk
buy viagra uk
buy swiss watches
cheap genaric viagra kamagra
buy lipitor
generic viagra cheap no prescription
buy cheap nexium emedoutlet
buy propecia
Buy viagra Arlington
buy crestor
generic viagra for sale
buy viagra no prescription
by diflucan
generic viagra pricing
buy levitra online
buy men watch
Buy viagra San Antonio
buy viagra from brazil
online viagra sale
buy panerai watch
buy protonix
online parmacy viagra cheap
generic viagra viagra
buy nolvadex drug
Buy cialis Las Vegas
online viagra for sale
online viagra order
Buy levitra Memphis
ordering viagra online
Buy viagra Modesto