As I’ve already commented here briefly, my answer is no.
Mark A. Altman at the Trek Movie Report thinks differently. As he says in his editorial “Star Trek Lives!“:
Indeed, it was Kirk himself who reminded us that galloping the cosmos is a game for the young and while I don’t envy J.J. Abrams task in re-casting [...]
Kirk and Spock travel to the planet Organia to convince them to let the Federation take on their planet as a base instead of the Klingons. The episode consists of Kirk arguing a lot with the Organians, who are peace-loving and do not intend (or ultimately need) to fight the Klingons.
This is an important episode, [...]
In watching the DVD extras after the film, I couldn’t help but wonder why the dorky screenwriter, wearing amber-shaded glasses indoors during his interview, got paid some sort of insane 6-figure amount for this botched remake. This has to rank up there with one of the worst remakes ever, built upon one of the worst [...]
Bad Behavior has blocked 477 access attempts in the last 7 days.
